Thailand's navy scraps its Hanwha frigate award and restarts the tender over a flawed bid rule
A Finance Ministry appeals ruling forces the Royal Thai Navy to rerun its 17 billion baht frigate tender; Hanwha Ocean can bid again and has gone to the ombudsman.
TAIPEI —
The Royal Thai Navy said on 18 November that it will cancel the procurement of a new high-performance frigate awarded to South Korea's Hanwha Ocean and start the tender again, after a government appeals body found that the bidding terms broke procurement rules.
Navy spokesman Rear Admiral Chanin Sriyaphai said the move follows a ruling by the Appeals and Complaints Review Committee of the Comptroller General's Department at the Finance Ministry, issued under Section 119 of the 2017 public procurement act, which ordered the process scrapped and run again.
The committee had upheld a complaint from the Thai Frigate Building Consortium, The Star reported, citing Thai media.
A missing threshold
The dispute centres on the experience requirement. Finance Ministry rules require a tender to set a minimum value for a bidder's past contracts, at no more than half of the project budget, or about 8.5 billion baht for this 17 billion baht programme. The navy's terms of reference asked only for proof of an earlier frigate construction contract and set no value.
The spokesman acknowledged that the terms were incomplete and not in line with the law, and said the navy would respect the ruling. He argued that no high-performance frigate anywhere costs as little as 8.5 billion baht, which is why the figure had been left out, and denied any corruption or tailoring of the specification to suit one bidder.
Hanwha can bid again
Hanwha Ocean offered 16.73 billion baht on 8 September and was chosen as the winning bidder that month, but no contract was ever signed. The spokesman said the navy did not expect to be sued, because the process had reached only the announcement of a winner and the company had not invested or spent money on the project.
The ruling does not disqualify any company, so Hanwha Ocean and other qualified shipbuilders can take part in the new round, the navy said.
Financial News reported that Hanwha Ocean has filed a petition with Thailand's ombudsman asking it to examine whether the cancellation was lawful. A Hanwha official told Businesskorea the company had learned of the decision through media reports, was checking the official notice and would review its response.
The project covers building and delivering one 4,000-ton-class frigate and providing maintenance and support afterwards, according to Financial News, which added that HD Hyundai Heavy Industries, unsuccessful in the first round, has not decided whether to bid again.
Racing a 2027 deadline
The cancellation dissolves every committee tied to the project, including those for project management, the draft terms of reference, the procurement itself and the offset policy. The navy must now appoint new committees and write new terms before it can invite bids again.
The spokesman admitted that the dispute had already cost the navy time. Under its budget framework, the purchase must be completed within the 2027 fiscal year, by September 2027, so the new process has to start quickly. The navy commander, Admiral Nares Wongtrakul, has ordered it to be run strictly, transparently and fast.
According to The Star, Admiral Nares said the frigate is still needed to protect Thai sovereignty and maritime interests. Two Turkish shipbuilders, ASFAT and TAIS Shipyards, were among the six original bidders, and the review comes a month after Turkey signed a military cooperation agreement with Cambodia, with which Thailand has a border dispute.
Sources
More in Indo-Pacific
Kim Jong Un calls a powerful navy North Korea's first strategic task on a naval university visit
Kim's 18 November tour of the Kim Jong Suk Naval University follows his warship, shipyard and naval base visits, pointing to a push to train crews for a growing fleet.
TaiwanDefence · 3h ago · 2 min read
Australia receives the first two of 13 extra MH-60R Seahawks as its navy helicopter fleet grows to 36
The submarine-hunting helicopters were unveiled at HMAS Albatross in Nowra on 19 November, with the other 11 aircraft due to arrive by early 2028.
TaiwanDefence · 8h ago · 2 min read
Japanese troops to train on Indian firing ranges as India and Japan speed up UNICORN mast transfer
Foreign and defence ministers meeting in Tokyo on 19 November also pushed for a reciprocal ship-repair deal and closer work on mine countermeasures.
TaiwanDefence · 10h ago · 3 min read
Discussion (0)
Comments are not currently available.